Menu of Firehouse Pizza - Morgantown in Morgantown, Kentucky, USA

Menu Overview

Firehouse Pizza - Morgantown crafts a pizza experience that feels both comforting and adventurous. Nestled in the heart of Morgantown, KY, this spot stands out by blending bold flavors with generous portions. The menu’s diverse offerings, from their signature 14" and 18" pizzas to unique sides and desserts, showcase a thoughtful approach to classic American pizza dining.

The Bullseye Pizza is a standout—a 14-inch masterpiece smothered in extra pepperoni, kissed with Tabasco before baking, and finished with a ranch swirl and a secret blend of seasonings. Each bite delivers a spicy, tangy punch balanced perfectly by the creamy ranch. Their 14" Chicken & Spinach Pizza surprises with tender grilled chicken, fresh spinach, mushrooms, and ricotta cheese layered over golden Italian sauce—comfort meets sophistication in every slice.

For those who gather in larger groups, the 18" Party Pizzas are a perfect fit. The Buffalo Chicken Pizza combines robust grilled chicken with Buffalo and ranch sauces, while the Cheese Addiction Pizza indulges cheese lovers with its rich cheddar sauce, Parmesan, and garlic butter. Meat enthusiasts find solace in the Meat Pizza loaded with pepperoni, sausage, beef, ham, and bacon. Each pie is crafted with a generous blend of pizza cheeses that never falls short, maintaining that perfect gooey texture and savory depth.

Beyond pizza, Firehouse Pizza surprises with their sides. The Chezburger Fries layer crinkle fries with beef, bacon, pickles, onions, cheddar, and pizza cheese, all topped with 1000 Island dressing—a bold, hearty snack. The Firehouse Fries, seasoned crinkle fries topped with ranch, bacon, and cheese, offer a satisfying crunch and rich flavor that complements the pizza offerings.

Desserts like their hand-scooped ice cream, sundaes, and the nostalgic Float 1 Scoop add a sweet finish to the meal. The Coffee Shake, a clever twist, blends creamy indulgence with a rich coffee kick, making it an unexpected menu highlight.

Customer feedback reinforces Firehouse Pizza’s quality and charm. Alexis Stephens praises the delicious flavors and generous portions despite a short wait, while James Hammock appreciates the hidden gem feeling of this Morgantown establishment, excitedly anticipating its Bowling Green reopening. Joe Sykes remarks on the genuinely flavorful toppings, and Tabitha Smith highlights the friendly staff, perfect cheese balance, and the special care taken in custom orders. Nicole Naasz’s experience with the “Eric” sandwich pizza, combined with the pay-as-you-drink draft beers, exemplifies the menu’s versatility and local-hearted spirit.

Firehouse Pizza - Morgantown propels small-town dining to a new level. It’s a place where bold seasoning, quality ingredients, and welcoming service intersect to create meals worth returning for. Whether indulging in their deep dish pepperoni, savoring wings, or enjoying a craft beer with a slice, every visit promises rich, satisfying flavors and a true sense of community.